Review: Jem and the Holograms Volume 1 - Showtime

With a deadline looming for entries into a music contest, singer-songwriter Jerrica Benton is gripped with anxiety and strage fright. Facing the prospect of dropping out and letting her bandmates down, Jerrica overcomes her fear by transforming into the glamorous Jem with the help of a holographic computer program created by her late father. After a splashy online debut, Jem and the Holograms achieve viral popularity – much to the chagrin of the spastic Misfits.

Jem and the Holograms Volume 1: Showtime collects issues 1-6 of Jem and the Holograms written by Kelly Thompson and illustrated by Sophie Campbell.

As a team, Kelly Thompson and Sophie Campbell were charged with a rather challenging task – update an iconic (and totally outrageous!) ‘80s cartoon for today’s comic book readership. What they accomplished was spectacular and inspired. They hit the ground running by telling the origins of the titular Jem and the Holograms, eschewing the villainous Eric Raymond and Starlight Records in favour of having their popularity stem from a music contest held by the Misfits (who have been seemingly established as an A-list rock group in this version). Thompson’s dialogue improves upon the characters we know and love from the cartoon, particularly giving them more distinct personalities that help the reader relate to them more. Aja is more sarcastic and has constant playful banter with Kimber, while Kimber herself is seen as an always-late flake that is as loud as she is talented. Shana sits comfortably as the voice of reason, filling the role of mediator whenever arguments arise. Interestingly, Thompson seems to lose Jerrica’s voice and personality in the process of fleshing out her sisters. I love the new dimension of Jerrica suffering from anxiety as it makes her easier to relate to personally and her relationship with Rio seems much more organic than it did in the cartoon, but she isn’t as pronounced as a savvy businesswoman and her quietness makes her seem dull in comparison to her bandmates.

From their debut onwards, Thompson and Campbell unravel a series of events that serve to develop the characters further. Kimber begins a secretive relationship with Stormer of the rival group the Misfits, Jerrica must contend with Rio’s negative perception of Jem (basically he thinks Jem is selfish and not a team player), and the Holograms pull double duty trying to prepare for the Mistfits’ music contest and a charity event for which they’ve volunteered their talent. The pacing is great as it moves the story along with a jaunty pace – occasionally tossing in splashy musical scenes artfully rendered by Campbell. The mix of interpersonal drama and their musical exploits is handled well, thankfully never veering too far into the melodrama box its animated predecessor often did. Thompson and Campbell work well together in this respect, as they’re able to balance camp with serious drama. Kimber’s relationship with Stormer becomes an emotional focal point for the readers. While there’s a humorous side to the subplot, it’s played straight (pardon the pun) and we see an impeccably well-written relationship that feels neither exploitative nor forced. It’s a development I love and one which helps to, not only endears me to, but relate to both Kimber and Stormer. On the other side of the equation, Thompson and Campbell do not pull back from the absolute insanity that is Pizzazz. They allow her to have epic meltdowns, often cumulating in fits of rage. It gels with her animated persona and it’s absolutely hilarious to see, made all the more gut-busting by Campbell’s unrivaled expressiveness.

While Thompson’s dialogue and plotting is flawless throughout, not nearly enough can be said about Campbell’s work as the book’s artist. It’s vibrant, outrageous, colourful, expressive, dynamic, glamorous, punk, girlie, sexy and a million other things. Everything from the way she draws hair to the special care she takes to create characters that are visually distinct from one another makes this book truly extraordinary. Part of what I love about this book is how inclusive it is. Not only is it explicitly and unapologetically LGBTQ+-friendly, but Campbell came up with a series of character designs that speak to today’s modern society. She gives the cast different body types, all of which more accurately reflect what we see in the real world. For instance, I adore that Stormer is portrayed as a desirable love interest for Kimber and as the key to the Misfits’ success (she writes their songs) rather than as the sassy or supportive best friend archetype as would usually be the case based on the body type Campbell draws her with here.

As one can imagine, it’s difficult trying to adapt the seminal Jem and the Holograms three decades later. Thompson and Campbell capture the fashion, aesthetic and nostalgia surrounding the series. The comics obviously lack the same structure, given the fact that each episode of Jem contained music videos and are comics a strictly visual medium, but does an admirable job of trying to stay true to the essence of the outrageous cartoon. There’s camp and drama – but most importantly there’s glamour, glitter, fashion and fame. Thompson and Campbell make me invested in these characters, while the latter especially creates a gloriously technicolour world full of distinctive musicians and crazy fashions. While it’s not a facsimile or a continuation of the original cartoon, Jem and the Holograms Volume 1: Showtime is a vibrant update on a classic. It’s clear that its creators have respect for the source material, so much so that we see little nods to the series via cameos (Ba Nee! Ashley! Lindsey Pierce!) and fashion choices. I thoroughly enjoyed this first set of issues and look forward to the rest.

RATING: A